Bricklemyer was selected through a national search. She has worked in the United Way system for 13 years, most recently serving as President and CEO of United Way of North Central Florida in Gainesville. Among her achievements there, Bricklemyer developed and implemented a network of research-based programs that targeted the barriers to school readiness through home visitation and teaching, parenting support, a mobile health van and food drives for children. She directed a grant from the Buffett Early Childhood Fund that energized Gainesville’s business sector in the advocacy of "early learning" opportunities for young children. Bricklemyer was appointed regional lead in Florida’s children’s initiative, and she chaired two county-wide efforts focused on children’s issues and poverty reduction. Campaign revenue increased 32% over five years under her direction.

CEO Search Committee Chair Terry Kroeger calls Bricklemyer an innovative leader who understands the need for United Way to be a catalyst for community changes. "Karen has strong experience in children’s issues and education, two things that are a priority here in the midlands. She is a proven fundraiser and knows how to build strong coalitions that help people become independent and productive members of our neighborhoods. Her skills and leadership will have a measurable impact on the quality of life for all who live here." Kroeger is president and publisher of the Omaha World-Herald; he will become UWM Board Chair in late March.

Bricklemyer's first formal role was to address the 425 guests at United Way’s annual meeting and awards luncheon on March 31.  She plans to spend the next several months meeting  key donors and volunteers, community leaders and executive teams at United Way's partner agencies.